2025 high school essay contest: 3rd place — Ian Klimov

FFRF awarded Ian $2,500.
By Ian Klimov
The running joke is: “two Jews, three opinions.” Add me in, and you get four — and not one of them includes God.
I was raised Jewish, the kind of Jewish that meant Shabbat candles sat next to Darwin’s “Origin of Species” on the bookshelf. We kept Passover but also kept Richard Dawkins in print. And still, my Bar Mitzvah was earnest: Hebrew school, Torah portion, suit and tie. The speeches were heartfelt and the bagels plentiful. But somewhere between the gefilte fish and the Haftarah, I realized: I don’t believe any of this; the parting of the sea or the talking bush, divine plan, the man in the sky, the afterlife with unlimited lox — none of it.
Setting aside the stupid things we think when we’re 13, overdressed and overwhelmed, there was another deep, evolutionary force at work that propelled those thoughts to my mind: cognitive dissonance. Our minds are restless, torn between conflicting beliefs. We experience mental discomfort when trying to reconcile two opposing beliefs. And eventually, the tension breaks. This was the day I had supposedly been building toward since I could walk. My parents beaming, my sisters squirming in their chairs, and me, standing there, utterly unmoved. Was I a bad person for having these thoughts? Had I let science books, TED Talks and Darwin chip away at my faith? No. I got cognitively dissonanced. And, after that day, I braced myself for the existential fallout — teenage angst with a theological twist. But what happened instead was . . . nothing. I found the sense that doing good didn’t require divine permission.
I’ve never stolen. I say thank you. I hold doors open for strangers, even when I’m in a rush. I co-led a neuroscience education group that translated research into public outreach, so others could access the same sense of curiosity that animates my studies. I mentor middle school violinists to prepare for annual music festivals. I conduct scientific research in molecular biology with the hopes to revolutionize medicine. I babysit for local families. I volunteer at NYU Langone Hospital in the pediatric emergency department every Saturday. None of this required scripture.
Morality, I’ve found, is most powerful when it’s chosen rather than inherited. When kindness is a commitment. Instead of asking the question “What would God want me to do?” I find myself inquiring “What kind of person do I want to be in a world that often forgets to ask?” When people say atheists can’t be moral, I wonder what morality they mean. Fear-based obedience? Or the kind built on empathy and reason, as well as the insistence that everyone deserves dignity, with or without divine endorsement?
If “doing good” is a religion, then sure, I’m devout. But my commandments aren’t written on stone tablets. And my temple? It’s the laboratory, the classroom, the stranger on the subway. I believe in doing good. And I don’t believe you need God to do it.
Ian, 18, is attending Yale University.
“I am planning to major in molecular, cellular and developmental biology, with the long-term goal of becoming a neurosurgeon. I’ve conducted research at Mount Sinai Hospital and Stony Brook University. I was the leader of the content creation team for Neuroscience Foundation, working with students to make research accessible to the public. I also served as concertmaster of my high school orchestra, performed violin for pediatric patients at NYU Langone Hospital, and tutored high school students in math and science.”