Freedom from religion foundation, Inc | Subscribe
Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc.

A convention conversation with Julia Sweeney

Julia Sweeney talks about how she wanted to be a nun when she was younger. “I just love the glamour of the nun life,” she said to laughs from the audience.
(Photo by Gonzo Pozo)
Actress/author Julia Sweeney and FFRF Co-President Dan Barker sat down for a humorous and insightful conversation on Oct. 28, 2022, in San Antonio.
(Photo by Chris Line)
Julia Sweeney tells Dan Barker about how her mother found out she was an atheist and says she regrets the way it happened. (Photo by Chris Line)

This is an edited and condensed version of the conversation between FFRF Co-President Dan Barker and actress and author Julia Sweeney on Oct. 28, 2022, at FFRF’s national convention in San Antonio. To watch the full conversation, go to ffrf.us/convention-2022.

 Dan: Ladies and gentlemen, Julia Sweeney.

Julia: Hello. I’m so happy to be here. I don’t ever want to miss another FFRF convention. It’s so important, now more than ever, sadly. But I couldn’t be happier to be here.

Dan: Just in case you don’t know, Julia Sweeney is an actress. She’s a comedian. She’s a playwright. She was a former “Saturday Night Live” cast member. She’s appeared in many movies, including “Pulp Fiction,” “Clockstoppers,” “Stuart Little.” And she produced and acted in “That’s Pat.” I really liked it.

Julia: You and eight other people in the world can get together and sing its praises.

Dan: She’s written a lot of monologues, and maybe you have seen them: “God said Ha!” and “Julia Sweeney: Older and Wider.”

Julia: That’s the latest one, yes.

Dan: Of course, my favorite is “Letting Go of God,” which tells your story of going from devout Catholic to atheist.

Julia: I wouldn’t say I was a devout Catholic. I was just a Catholic. I didn’t look into it that much. I used God when it was convenient for me and I lived a secular life when it wasn’t convenient for me. I think that’s how most people probably use the idea of God. 

But then I went through a personal crisis where I experienced this thing where I felt like God came to me and said that this situation was gonna be all right. I feel like I had a really full-on religious experience.

Dan: You really believed that God was talking to you?

Julia: Well, I didn’t think there was a guy coming down and saying things. Every time I try to describe it, it seems like I’m making it up and it isn’t accurate. I just had this feeling that it was going to be all right. It was powerful and I did make a big leap into feeling better. The idea of God worked — the idea that I felt loved and everything was gonna work out. But afterward, I was very curious about that experience. Like, what actually happened? Was it really God? And then I decided I should take it more seriously. I joined the local Santa Monica church, and I took a bible studies class. I was in my 30s. 

But reading other books, such as How We Believe, by Michael Shermer, which also referenced other books, had me going from one book to another. So, I did learn more about what happens in the brain and why that thing might have happened to me. Anyway, “Letting Go of God” is that story, but with jokes.

Dan: You did say for a while you thought you might want to be a nun.

Julia: Yes, absolutely, I wanted to be a nun. To me, I just love the glamour of the nun life. I think it had a lot to do with all the nun movies I watched. “The Trouble with Angels” was a big one for me. I wanted to be like Rosalind Russell. It was like the movie version of Catholicism is what I wanted to be. I didn’t realize I just wanted to be an actress. 

And, also, when I was growing up, and I think it’s still partly true, the nuns were the feminists. The nuns were the women who chose not to be married, who chose to be activists. I thought if you only had two roads to choose between, motherhood and being a nun, I mean, being a nun seemed quite great. 

Dan: You did say in the play that you had a picture of Jesus on the wall that you fantasized about. So, being married to Jesus, you’re a woman with feelings.

Julia: I’m still marveling at how religion works on so many levels. Like, it really delivers on so many levels. And yet, it’s so wrong and so insidious and so corrupting of our society all at the same time. But, as an institution, you can be not a bright person and be in it. You can be a smart person and be in it. You can have an emotional relationship with it. Like, it’s a big spectrum of things. And yeah, the whole idea of Jesus loving you. This person in the sky, make him attractive, looking out for you, knows all your trials and tribulations and he’s there to comfort you. Of course, that’s like the perfect boyfriend.

Dan: Another line I like in “Letting Go of God”: “Humor and laughter give a drug kick to the back of the brain.” And when you’re in front of an audience and the audience laughs, you get this kind of . . .

Julia: It’s addictive. It is great. It’s funny, because on March 26 [2022], I filmed “Julia Sweeney: Older and Wider” in Spokane, at the theater where I had my first job and saw my first movie. I thought a lot about that experience. To me, that was what church was, it was theater. And there was actually a theater and then there were movies. How powerful that was to me. I just wanted to be part of it. And, of course, I like being funny and I like being on stage and making people laugh. But that is the last show I’m gonna do like that. And I don’t have the need for it like I used to have to get those laughs. 

Dan: You wrote the book If It’s Not One Thing, It’s Your Mother. Are you gonna write more?

Julia: Yes. I have a few ideas for books in my head. If I could get myself to do it.

Dan: Tell them about the title.

Julia: That came from a pillow my mother gave me that said, “If it’s not one thing, it’s your mother.” It’s not that funny. Then I became a mother myself and it was suddenly hysterical. And then I gave it to my daughter. She’s like, “This is not that funny.” And I was like, “Oh, it will be.” So, that’s where that came from.

Dan: Are you working on something else?

Julia: Writing-wise, yes. I spent the pandemic reading. For various reasons, I fell into this whole Cass Elliott craziness. She was in the band the Mamas and the Papas. I started obsessively reading about her life and I wanted to write a screenplay about her life. I worked for a year on that. And then I got it to several producers who all said it should be more straightforward. But I feel like it should be more magical realism. So, I’m continuing to work on that. And I really do like the writing. 

Dan: In the entertainment industry, TV and movies, is religion a problem? I mean, is atheism a problem in Hollywood?

Julia: Well, no. Of course, Hollywood is a huge business with all kinds of people and all kinds of religious feelings, so it’s impossible to say everyone is one way or another. What I noticed the most when I did “Letting Go of God” was all my Hollywood acquaintances said, “Oh, I can’t believe you were ever a believer. That was ridiculous. But I want you to meet with my astrologer.” So, I realize, they have just as many superstitions, but they just aren’t religious. I mean, traditionally religious. But they’re still superstitious. 

Dan: Can you tell the story about how your mother learned you’re an atheist? She read it in the paper, right?

Julia: In a way, that was terrible of me. I was losing my faith and I was doing stand-up. So, I was just talking about what was happening in my life. I was explaining my questioning of it, and what I learned in the bible and what I learned from my reading. And then I kind of started putting it together into a show. And I spoke in D.C. and that was the first time I kind of put it all together. My hometown paper, on an inner page, had the story, “Julia Sweeney comes out as an atheist.” I had no idea there was a reporter there.

First of all, it never occurred to me that would be a headline in the Spokane paper. But it was. And it was really humiliating for my parents. It was really upsetting. But, as I get older now, because now it’s been 20 or so years since I did that, I do feel bad about it. I wish I had protected them a little more. 

My mother called up and was like, “You are not an atheist.” And I was like, “What are you gonna do about it?” And then she said the priests at Gonzaga are gonna talk to you and you’re gonna come to Spokane and you’re gonna go have dinner with the priests and they’re gonna explain to you. And I said, “Bring it on. Convince me. Is there some information I don’t have that I need?”

So, I went to Spokane and went to that dinner. I didn’t put this in my show because I kind of wanted to protect the priests because they were so inept. The whole idea that I had of these priests was that these were Jesuits, the smart priests. But, they basically were like, “You don’t believe in God?” 

“No.”

“You know better than Thomas Aquinas?”

“Well, I actually think Thomas Aquinas would be an atheist if he were around now. He just didn’t have the scientific information.” 

“Oh, you know more than St. Augustine?” 

“Well, I have more access to more information than he had.” 

I didn’t know where it was going. And then one of the priests said, “What’s it like to live in Hollywood?”

They just wanted to ask me if I had met so and so? One of those priests, who I still follow on Twitter, has become a crazy right-wing Catholic nutcase. And yet he’s so into Hollywood. But I realize they had nothing. I mean, they really didn’t have any arguments. 

I left there and my mother said, “So, are you a Catholic again?”

“No, they don’t know anything. And they can’t even argue with you about it.”

She was so upset and then she wouldn’t speak to me for nine months.

Dan: But it wasn’t just Gonzaga. Didn’t you talk to someone high up in the Vatican, actually? 

Julia: I had correspondences with a couple of priests at the Vatican. They don’t have anything, either. The thing is, it’s based on nothing. They give up very quickly. I really was looking forward to a good debate. They kind of make it like, “How could you know anything?” A little bit like that. And a little bit of flattery and a little bit of, “Oh, I’m just the old parish priest.” Or, “This is a great institution that’s helped a lot of people.” In some ways, it probably has helped some people. But, it’s done a lot more damage than good, I would say. But I can’t deny that it isn’t helpful to some people. 

But, yeah. I talk to a Vatican priest and sometimes we DM each other. He said I should come to the Vatican this time and he’ll show me around?

Dan: Would you go?

Julia: Oh, my god. Of course, I’d go. 

But, I was so horrified with what was happening with the Catholics. My assessment is that all of the normal people left and all the crazies stayed. And the right-wing authoritarian, patriarchal people with the worst of the worst is left. I think Pope Francis is trying to do what he can. But I think when the next pope comes, he’ll be more of a right-wing pope.

And then the Supreme Court was so upsetting. There’s so many Catholics. The cabal on the Supreme Court is mostly Catholic. I just couldn’t believe this religion that I grew up with — this kind of social justice Catholicism of the ’70s, this kind of kumbaya stuff, the priests that were really great — has now just become horrible, right wing, punitive, angry. It’s just upsetting. 

Dan: Politics or abortion or gay rights, were any of those an issue in Spokane in your upbringing?

Julia: No. Because there’s nobody gay and there’s no abortions. My mom would say, “No one is gay. Being gay is a fad. People are gay to become popular. And then when they get in their 30s, they realize and they just marry someone so they can have a family. Which is what everyone wants.”

And then abortion. It took me so long to understand that D&C [dilation and curettage] was code for abortion in Catholic hospitals. You can’t do an abortion. But you can have this procedure. We had five kids in my family and we were the smallest family I knew of. The smallest of everyone around us, including the people three doors down who had 17 children.

Dan: Like shanty Irish Catholics.

Julia: Yeah, lots of kids. And sometimes mothers would go need a D&C and they would go to the hospital and get a D&C. I didn’t realize until later that was all code language for getting an abortion. The wives knew. The husbands didn’t know what was happening.

Dan: Why do you think they care so much now?

Julia: Because they like the secrecy. You say this, but you do that. That’s the most interesting thing. There’s something about hiding what you really do that is part of the system that they like. It’s not that they don’t do those things. Of course, there are people who are gay and people acting out on it. And people who were couples who were gay, but no one would openly acknowledge it, and that was kind of part of it. We all know that’s true, but we all know not to say anything about it.

Dan: At a former meeting, you told us about an experience where you were visiting a different church every Sunday and writing a book about it?

Julia: Dan, all I do is talk about the books I want to write and not write them.

Dan: That would be an amazing book.

Julia: Ha! That’s true. I moved to Chicago for 10 years and had never lived there before. Every Sunday, I’d go to a different church. You walk in, it’s like being in somebody’s living room. You see it, how everyone interacts. I did that for a year and it was enlightening. That’s how I discovered the Unitarians. And I joined the Unitarians in Evanston (Ill.). I got choked up at the Unitarian church. It was the first time I was in a church where I didn’t disagree with everything that was said. It was emotional for me and I really liked that experience. And I found another Unitarian church in Pasadena when I moved to L.A. 

At the Unitarian church in Evanston, I became part of the committee that welcomed a religious Syrian family that was fleeing. I was part of the group taking care of this seven-person family. That got me into understanding the refugee situation and working with Secular Rescue. I know you guys support Secular Rescue, too. 

Right now, I’m working with a guy from Bangladesh. He’s actually in hiding in India right now, but he’s from Chittagong [in Bangladesh]. I interviewed him thinking I would write a book about it. Clearly, I don’t write the books. I just interview people. I started interviewing this guy, who’s about 30 years old. He was living in Chittagong and just started having a Sunday afternoon “let’s talk about the Quran” chat. He was becoming an atheist. He did that for two years. The version of ISIS over there started threatening him. He got afraid. They put an “X” on his family’s door, saying this is where he lives, which is frightening. And his brother became an atheist, an out atheist. Three years ago, he was at a mall where three guys with machetes attacked him. He was stabbed many times. It’s amazing he survived. They severed the sciatic nerve in one of his legs. A tuk-tuk driver came, and the public hospital wouldn’t get involved in that. So, he went to another hospital, and ended up living, but they were coming back to finish the job. Through the work of Secular Rescue — the money and the help — he got to Calcutta, India, on a medical visa. 

I became close to him, and I talk to him three times a week. In fact, I just sent him pictures from this convention. He’s really become like a son. He’s in line to go to Canada. He might be having to wait another year until he actually can get to Canada, but that helped me get into Secular Rescue and then really reading about what was happening in these different countries. 

Now I’m thinking that I want to do an ad that I could do to raise money for Secular Rescue that could be like FFRF’s Ron Reagan Jr. ad. If it was funded, it could be on TV. But you only have 30 seconds. And I don’t want to say “Islam.” I don’t want people to think it’s Islamophobia. When I stopped believing in God and left the Catholic Church, my parents were so mad at me they didn’t speak to me for nine months. But they didn’t try to kill me. You know what I mean? Something along the lines of saying the freedoms we have here, you could still have a lot of emotional cost, but you’re not gonna be killed for it. But there are places where you can be killed for doing that. And this is an organization that helps! That’s where I want to put my energies.

Dan: Amazing. Thank you.