Freedom from religion foundation, Inc | Subscribe
Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc.

Betty Johnson: ‘Good Books’ in need of good disposition

By Betty Johnson

I had two generations worth of life to clear from my mom’s four-bedroom house after she died. A big part of that job was books, because my mom read at least two books per month right up until her end at 87 years old. After gathering up all the books, some going back many decades, I ended up donating 38 bags of books to the charity Friends of the Library.

I found five bibles among all the books, but I held those back from the donation because I wasn’t sure how I wanted to deal with them.

My mom was raised going to a Methodist church for the dress-up holidays, and my parents were married in a Methodist church, but after that, our family didn’t attend church.

My family was nonreligious my whole life, for which I’ve always been grateful. The only time I remember having an adult conversation with my mom about God was in the last year or two of her life when I had said something about being a nonbeliever, which she knew, and she said, “You know that’s not how I feel, right?” and I said yes, I did know that. And that was the end of the conversation. Then she moved on to happily threatening to haunt me if I ever told a story about her. So, if it turns out I’m wrong about my beliefs, “Hi Mom!”

Most of the bibles I find at Mom’s house were inherited from generations past, so prior to serious contemplation of the bibles’ disposition, I flip through the pages of all five bibles, looking for any handwriting. Or money. Being a devout capitalist, I’m hoping to find a bit of cash to add to the $14 in long-forgotten winnings that I found in the back of Mom’s desk drawer next to a lottery form. Alas, these bibles do not give up any shekels.

I find no dates of births, marriages or deaths, or anything else of family historical significance in the bibles, except for one handwritten note that was signed by my great granddad: “After I lost Emily, the whole world became hard. . . I could not rely on those I felt would never falter . . . It is terrible to realize that those most trusted fail for it has been proven to me.”

From the prominent placement of his pronouncement — the inside front cover of a bible — he clearly wanted his feelings known, so I’ll say this: Your message of deep disappointment has been received, great-granddad, and, sadly, I can relate.

My first thought is to give the bibles to my mom’s caregiver. She loved my mom a lot, but she’s a born-again Christian and I don’t want to give her a reason to attach sentimentality to books that I feel don’t deserve it — books which have been used for thousands of years to oppress and instill fear in people and which contain shocking cruelty, inconsistent and confounding teachings, acceptance of heinous activities toward other human beings, and egregious omissions from the 10 guiding principles.

I intend to have an estate sale at some point, but 1) I don’t want to profit from selling these bibles, and 2) in my grief and fatigue, I’m just not up to a potential conversation with someone who might be interested in buying the bibles: Why are you selling them? You don’t believe in God? Don’t you worry about . . .? No, I do not.

Side note: I did end up having a God conversation at the estate sale with a fabulously dressed woman who stopped by on her way home from church. She’s interested in buying a sculptural framed Nefertiti which had hung over my mom’s bed. This woman tells me about how she had gotten Covid, and how God’s grace had saved her.

Treading lightly, I ask why she thinks God had saved her and not the hundreds of thousands of other Christian Americans who had lost their lives to Covid. (This was in 2021). She thinks for a moment, then answers, “You know, I don’t know why I was saved, but it’s not our place to question. God has a plan.” She bought the Nefertiti. I remain a nonbeliever.

With so much work to do, I kick the bible disposition decision down the road for several months while I clear Mom’s house in the hours before and after working my remote job.

But, finally, when there’s not much left in Mom’s house, I need to address what to do with the bibles. I wonder if there’s a standard protocol for getting rid of old bibles, like for an old American flag. My mom had an old, faded U.S. flag that I wanted to dispose of, so I had left messages at the VA, the VFW, and the Boy Scouts (I had read they pick up old flags and burn them). But none of those places returned my calls, so I left that old, faded flag in the garage for the new owners of Mom’s house. I just couldn’t make myself throw it in the trash.

At this point, I’m too exhausted to research if old bible disposition protocols exist.

I’d been doing a lot of shredding over the past few months — tax returns, bank statements, mortgage documents, etc. — so, with no other option feeling right and time running out, I finally decide: I’m just going to shred the bibles.

I do realize it says something about me and my beliefs that I revere the American flag more than these bibles. I’m OK with that.

It’s time: I take the bibles into Mom’s office and pull out the shredder. Fahrenheit 451 comes to mind. Oh, good grief. . . I’m not making a political statement, I argue with myself; I’m not stopping anyone from reading other bibles. In fact, I wish people would read the bible more, but use critical thinking with an eye toward history and consider how humans should treat one another in a civilized society.

So, I’m taking just these five bibles out of circulation. Quietly, in a room by myself, no fist-shaking, no fires. Well, not so much in quiet, as accompanied by the noise of the shredder. But, definitely no fires.

As I start to rip pages from the first bible prior to feeding the maw of the shredder, I get a queasy feeling in my gut. Oh, come on . . .

I thought this was settled. I have no sentimental or religious attachment to these books, so what’s giving me pause?

Then it comes to me: My queasy gut is evidence of my discomfort, not with the content of these books, but with the fact that they are books and I love books, as did my mom. But, sometimes, for books about which you have strong negative feelings, it really is OK to let those books go.

I get a shredding rhythm going that feels like choreography. I find I can rip pages out with my left hand, and use my right to put them through the shredder; left hand rip, right hand shredder, riiiip, whirrr, riiip, whirr . . .it’s like I’m rehearsing for a heathen version of Stomp.

The shredded paper from the first bible is surprisingly soft. Soft paper? I had never encountered such a thing. The paper from the other shredding I had been doing, bank statements, etc., was rough and, well, normal. The internet tells me that bible paper is typically wood-free and contains cotton or linen fibers. Well, OK, if this comes up at pub trivia, I’ll be ready.

I pull the next bible from the stack, the bible with my great-granddad’s handwritten note. I tear off the cover on which he had written his note and I set it aside. I don’t know what I’ll do with it, but as I have such a visceral understanding of his disappointment in those close to him in a time of grieving, it feels keep-worthy for now.

While tearing out the pages from my mom’s youth bible, I catch some of the more disturbing chapter headings:

• “A spring sweetened by salt; and water that looked like blood.”

• “The rich man’s son sold as a slave.”

• “The reign of fire that fell on a city.”

I feel umbrage bubbling up — such stories in a youth bible! — but then I think of Edward Gorey, Roald Dahl, the Brothers Grimm, and my umbrage meter returns to zero.

Then I also see — “Jonathan’s love for David” — admirably progressive for a kid’s bible.

Just then, the shredder starts acting up. Some people would say this is a sign that I shouldn’t be shredding bibles. No, no, it’s simply a sign of an overworked shredder due years of accumulations of paperwork. Nothing more.

Sadness and grief over the death of a loved one can spin the mind to dark places and mid-shred through the last bible, I contemplate what would happen if I have a heart attack and keel over dead right now. When someone finds me, they’ll see shredded bible detritus all over the floor. They might presume I was angry at God, and that I was struck down for destroying these books.

Stop, I tell myself. And I bring the curtain down on this mini drama, deciding to save my dwindling energy reserves for more important contemplations.

And suddenly, that’s it. I’ve finished the task. Now let me get these bags out to the recycle bin.

Betty Johnson is an FFRF member from California.