Freedom from religion foundation, Inc | Subscribe
Published by the Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc.

Sammi Lawrence: Dangerous fake abortion clinics on the rise

By Sammi Lawrence

The assault on abortion access continues as predatory faith-based women’s “health care” outfits move into locations where now-defunded Planned Parenthoods once stood. Crisis pregnancy centers are taking the place of these clinics — like Christian nationalist Spirit of Halloween stores.

For those unfamiliar, crisis pregnancy centers are religious faux clinics that claim to provide women’s health care, erecting a facade that implies the crisis pregnancy centers are willing and able to provide a full range of reproductive health care services to patients. Most, if not nearly all, of these centers are affiliated with and inspired by evangelical Christianity, though that’s not always clear to patients upfront, since their websites and advertisements often conveniently leave out their religious affiliations.

In reality, crisis pregnancy centers are not staffed by real doctors or nurses. They traditionally entice women by offering free pregnancy tests or free ultrasounds, which many states require abortion patients to undergo as part of targeted restrictions on abortion providers. And, sadly but unsurprisingly, many of these centers are receiving millions in taxpayer dollars to lie to and frighten pregnant people. It is a travesty that since Roe v. Wade was overturned, states overall have increased their funding of fake crisis pregnancy centers by about $500 million. Anti-abortion ideology masquerading as health care is being subsidized by us taxpayers, a majority of whom support legal abortion.

To repeat: Crisis pregnancy centers are not real health care clinics. They don’t provide actual reproductive care, and many of them operate unethically, spreading misinformation to people in need of real medical advice in an effort to convince women not to have abortions. According to the American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists, crisis pregnancy centers “actually aim to dissuade people from accessing certain types of reproductive health care, including abortion care and even contraceptive options.”

Real doctors and health care professionals are bound by ethical guidelines and laws meant to protect patients. For example, your doctor can’t lie to you about a diagnosis, purposely give you incorrect medical advice, or share your personal information with anyone without your consent.

In contrast, crisis pregnancy centers are unregulated. This means that clinics and staff aren’t subject to the same laws as actual doctors, including HIPAA. They don’t have to provide patient confidentiality like real medical professionals do. Carrie Baker, a professor of gender, law and public policy at Smith College, has expressed concern that crisis pregnancy centers are collecting data on pregnant women in order to create a national database that could be used for criminal prosecutions if Christian nationalists succeed in criminalizing abortion nationally.

A recent PBS news report provides an example of how one woman was tricked by a Boston-area center. Hana Miller recounted to reporters how she searched for reproductive care clinics after discovering she had an unwanted pregnancy. She stumbled upon a website for a clinic that looked legitimate and made an appointment, and she described the inside of the “clinic” as looking “exactly like any doctor’s office, down to a woman in scrubs.” But halfway through the appointment, Hana realized she’d made a mistake and was at a crisis pregnancy center, not a real doctor’s office. The staff member at the center who was essentially providing Hana with unlicensed medical care even incorrectly told Hana she was eight weeks pregnant, when she was actually only six weeks pregnant. This isn’t surprising, given that crisis pregnancy centers use unethical and misleading means to convince women not to get abortions, including outright lying about how far along their pregnancies are. Thankfully, Hana was able to receive real medical care elsewhere, but other women are often not so lucky.

The legal avenues for fighting crisis pregnancy centers are murky, at best. After California enacted a law requiring centers to provide clients with accurate information, the Supreme Court ruled in 2018 that it was unconstitutional on free speech grounds.

In New York, Attorney General Letitia James sought to prevent specific centers in the state from promoting “abortion pill reversal” — a fake and dangerous unproven medical treatment that claims to reverse the effects of medication abortion. James argued the crisis pregnancy centers have made false and misleading statements to patients by claiming that the abortion pill reversal treatment works. Notably, one study that attempted to examine the efficacy of abortion pill reversal was shut down early after only 12 women signed up and three of the women “required ambulance transport to a hospital for treatment of severe vaginal bleeding.” Unfortunately, a federal appellate court recently upheld a preliminary injunction that prevents the AG’s office from taking action against the centers while the case proceeds. The appellate court agreed with the lower court’s conclusion that the AG’s actions likely violate the free speech rights of these centers. According to the court, the First Amendment allegedly protects the “free speech right” of crisis pregnancy centers to lie to pregnant people and tell them that a fake and dangerous treatment works.

A new case is before the U.S. Supreme Court, First Choice Women’s Resource Centers Inc. v. Platkin, which yet again examines the “free speech” rights of crisis pregnancy centers. In Platkin, the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs began investigating First Choice, one such center, over concerns that its website and advertising practices misled donors and clients, as well as allegations of misleading medical advice and unlicensed staff performing medical services that require professional credentials. During the investigation, New Jersey sought documents from First Choice, including advertising materials, donor information and information on staff. First Choice objected to the requests on First Amendment grounds while the state case continued. Now, the Supreme Court is poised to decide whether the First Amendment provides a cover for First Choice to avoid giving New Jersey materials it needs to build a case against it.

Regardless of whether crisis pregnancy centers have free speech rights, they’re still a target for lawsuits by patients they harm. In 2023, a Massachusetts woman filed a class action lawsuit against a center, Clearway Clinic, after the clinic failed to diagnose her ectopic pregnancy. The plaintiff claimed that the Clearway Clinic “nurse” who performed an ultrasound on her did not adequately inspect her for an ectopic pregnancy, and, about a month after the appointment, the plaintiff’s fallopian tube ruptured, leading to a life-threatening emergency. The plaintiff further claimed that the center used false and misleading advertising tactics. The parties ultimately settled the case in 2024 after a court declined to dismiss the suit.

After the Clearway case, the Massachusetts Legislature passed a law requiring pregnancy ultrasound services to be supervised by licensed medical professionals who provide medical care for pregnant people as part of their practice. The law aims to crack down on crisis pregnancy centers and protect the public, and it provides an example of what lawmakers in other states can do to fight such entities. The Massachusetts law is crafted in a way that does not clearly set the stage for a First Amendment challenge, and states have a legally recognized interest in regulating the practice of medicine. Massachusetts further launched a campaign to explain to the public what crisis pregnancy centers are, why they’re dangerous, and how to spot them. The campaign was advertised on social media, billboards, radio and public transit.

Beyond legal and legislative fixes, there’s always good old-fashioned public education. Private organizations must educate people about crisis pregnancy centers and why they’re dangerous. In the post-Roe landscape, public education is perhaps our most important tool. While laws and lawsuits are an important part of the fight, the best way to attack crisis pregnancy centers is to persuade people not to go to them in the first place.

Sammi Lawrence is an FFRF staff attorney.